Blog

·

For owners

Top mistakes business owners make when approached by a buyer

Got an unsolicited offer for your company? Avoid the 8 mistakes that cost business owners leverage, price and months of exclusivity.

·

6 min read

·

Triwell Partners

Key takeaways

Don’t name your number first. Ask for a written range with assumptions and benchmark your value independently.

Protect sensitive data. Sign an NDA with non-solicit terms and share information in stages.

Limit exclusivity. In Axial’s 2025 data, failed deals had locked sellers in for 104 days on average.

Compare what you take home. A $30 million offer can be worth less than a $26 million one.

Quick answer: The costliest mistakes are naming a price first, sharing sensitive information too early, talking to only one buyer, signing a vague offer letter that locks you in, and letting the business slip during the sale. Slow down, know what your business is worth, and line up alternatives before you commit.

Why do unsolicited offers catch business owners off guard?

A call from a private equity firm or a larger company in your industry is flattering, and it usually comes when you aren’t planning to sell. The buyer has done this dozens of times; most business owners sell once. That experience gap is where money gets left on the table, often months later, during the buyer’s review or at closing.

What are the biggest mistakes business owners make when a buyer calls?

1. Treating the first call as a compliment instead of a process

Many of these calls are buyers building their pipeline, not a firm plan to pay top dollar. Respond politely, ask what they like about your business and how they’d pay for a deal, and commit to nothing on the first call.

2. Naming your number first

The first number sets the range for the whole negotiation. If you say it, it becomes the ceiling, not the floor. Ask the buyer to put a price range in writing and explain how they got there, and get your own independent valuation before you respond.

3. Sharing sensitive data before you have a plan

Customer lists, profit margins and employee pay are valuable to a competitor, and some ‘buyers’ are exactly that. Sign a confidentiality agreement (NDA) that also bars them from poaching your customers or staff, share information in stages, and hold back the most sensitive details until you have a written offer.

4. Signing a vague offer letter that locks you in

A letter of intent (LOI) is the buyer’s written offer. Most include exclusivity: once you sign, you can’t talk to other buyers, and your negotiating power drops sharply. In Axial’s 2025 data on sales that fell apart after the LOI, the pattern was clear: deals that eventually failed had locked sellers in for months first.

Bar chart: days owners were locked in with one buyer before a failed deal broke, by buyer type in 2025: 104 days on average, up to 159 for lender-led buyers.

That’s months of lost alternatives, legal fees and distraction, with nothing to show for it. Before you sign, pin down the details: how much cash you get at closing, any money held back or paid later, whether you must reinvest, and your role after the sale. Limit exclusivity to a realistic timeline, with a way out if the buyer misses deadlines.

5. Negotiating with only one buyer

A single buyer has no reason to stretch. Even if you prefer one buyer, quietly checking interest from two or three others changes how hard they bid. Research on large deals shows negotiated sales can reach prices similar to auctions, but only when the seller has credible alternatives (see our guide to proprietary sourcing vs. auctions).

6. Taking your eye off the business

The buyer’s review can run three to four months, and they watch your monthly numbers the whole time. In 2025 data on failed deals, the business slowing down during the sale killed 8.0% of them, and failed renegotiations, often after a dip or a surprise, killed another 14.7%. Keep a trusted leader running the company while you focus on the deal.

7. Focusing on the headline price instead of what you’ll take home

A $30 million offer can be worth less than a $26 million offer. If much of the $30 million is paid later based on performance, paid as a loan from you to the buyer, or held back to cover future claims, you may never see all of it. Compare offers on what you’ll actually take home after taxes, and how certain it is, not the headline number.

8. Not knowing what you want after the sale

Only 41% of owners have a written plan for life after exit, and research on owners who have sold suggests as many as 75% deeply regret it within a year (Entrepreneur). Business owners without a plan are more likely to stall or back out mid-deal: sellers backing out caused 13.3% of broken LOIs in 2025.

What should you say when a buyer calls?

• “Thanks for reaching out. We’re not actively selling, but I’m always open to learning about good partners.”

• “What specifically about our business interests you, and how would a deal be funded?”

• “Before we share anything, we’d need an NDA. Can you send your standard form?”

• “If you’d like to propose something, please put a range and your key assumptions in writing.”

• Then talk to your own advisors before the second conversation.

FAQ: Responding to an unsolicited acquisition offer

Should I respond to an unsolicited offer to buy my company? Yes, politely, but don’t negotiate on the first call. Learn who the buyer is, how they would fund a deal and what they value, then benchmark your company before sharing data or discussing price.

Who should name a price first in a business sale? Ideally the buyer. The first number anchors the negotiation, so ask for a written range with assumptions and compare it to an independent valuation before you respond.

How long should exclusivity last? Only as long as the buyer realistically needs to finish their review, with deadlines they must meet and a way out for you if they don’t. In 2025 data on failed deals, sellers had been locked in for roughly 37 to 159 days, depending on the type of buyer.

What percentage of signed offers fail to close? Industry sources commonly estimate that about a quarter to a third of signed letters of intent for privately held companies never close. Problems found during the buyer’s review are now the leading cause.

Do I need an M&A advisor if a buyer approached me directly? Not always, but an advisor protects your negotiating power: checking what your business is worth, bringing in other buyers, negotiating the offer and managing the buyer’s review. Business owners usually sell once; buyers do it every year.

How can an M&A advisor help when a buyer approaches you?

Buyers negotiate acquisitions every year; most business owners sell once. An advisor on your side closes that experience gap, whether or not you decide to sell:

A confidential first read. An assessment of who the buyer is, how they typically structure deals and whether their interest looks real, before your second conversation.

Know your number first. An independent benchmark of your value, so you never anchor the negotiation against yourself.

Real alternatives. Credible options from the private equity firms, family investment offices and private equity-owned companies actively buying in your industry.

An offer that protects you. Negotiation of the deal structure, cash at closing and exclusivity limits before you sign, not after.

Someone to run the deal while you run the company. Management of the buyer’s review and requests so the business doesn’t slip while the sale is underway.

How Triwell Partners fits in

Triwell Partners works on the buy side. Private equity firms, family offices and independent sponsors engage us to find founder-owned companies that fit what they want to buy, before a sale process starts. If we reach out about your company, we’ll tell you what kind of buyer is interested and why your business fits, with no obligation to go further. We act for the buyer in those conversations, so keep your own M&A attorney and CPA, and an advisor of your own if you want one, for your side of any deal.

Sources

Axial, “Dead Deal Report: Unpacking 2025’s Broken LOIs”: reasons LOIs broke and days under exclusivity by buyer type.

Entrepreneur, “75% of Entrepreneurs Regret Their Exit” (May 2026), citing Exit Planning Institute 2023 owner-readiness figures.

The buyer has done this dozens of times; most business owners sell once.

Thinking about what comes next?

Send us a few lines about where things stand. One of us will reply within one business day, with no obligation to go further.

General information only, not legal, tax or investment advice. Triwell Partners is a buy-side advisor: we are engaged and paid by buyers, not sellers.