Blog
·
For owners
Proprietary sourcing vs. auctions: how to choose your sale process
Auctions and negotiated sales reach similar final premiums, but negotiated deals close about two months faster. How to choose the right sale process.
·
5 min read
·
Triwell Partners
Key takeaways
Final prices are similar. Research on 1,300+ completed US deals found auctions and negotiated sales reached similar final premiums.
Negotiated deals are faster. They reached a signed deal 62 days sooner on average.
Alternatives are the leverage. Negotiated sales only keep pace with auctions when the seller has credible other options.
Most sales sit in between. A targeted process keeps competition without the noise of a broad auction.
Quick answer: In a proprietary (negotiated) sale, you deal with one or a few hand-picked buyers. In an auction, an advisor runs a formal process with many bidders. Auctions create more competition; negotiated sales are faster and more private. Research on 1,300+ deals found similar final prices, with negotiated deals closing about two months sooner.
What is the difference between a proprietary deal and an auction?
A proprietary deal is a sale negotiated with a single buyer, or a very small group, usually because the buyer contacted you directly or an advisor made the introduction. Buyers like the term because it means they found your company without having to bid against others.
An auction is a formal sale process. Your advisor prepares a short anonymous summary and a detailed company profile, contacts dozens or even hundreds of potential buyers, collects early price ranges, then narrows the field to a few finalists who submit written offers (letters of intent) by a deadline.
Most real-world sales sit between the two. A targeted process contacts a short list of well-qualified buyers, keeping some competition without the noise of a broad auction.
What does the data say about auctions vs. negotiated sales?
Research on more than 1,300 completed US deals (1994 to 2016) finds roughly a 50/50 split between auctions and negotiated sales. Negotiated sales reached a signed, announced deal much faster, while the time from announcement to close was about the same (Liu and Officer data, as reviewed by Analysis Group in Law360).

Price tells a more surprising story. Opening offers were lower in negotiated sales, about 30.5% above the company’s market value versus 38.5% in auctions. But sellers who negotiated won bigger increases during private talks (9.4 percentage points versus 7.3), and final prices ended up similar. Late counteroffers from rival buyers after a deal was announced were equally rare either way, at about 14% to 15% of deals.
Two caveats matter for business owners. First, this research covers large public companies (over $100 million), not privately held businesses, where there are fewer buyers and less public information. Second, economic research on auctions points the other way: adding even one more serious bidder is usually worth more than skilled one-on-one negotiation (Bulow and Klemperer). The practical takeaway: competition is valuable, but a buyer’s belief that you have other options can be almost as valuable as a full auction.
How do proprietary deals and auctions compare?

When does an auction make sense?
• Many buyers, from larger companies in your industry to private equity firms, are likely to want your company.
• Your financials are clean and independently reviewed, so they’ll hold up when several buyers dig in.
• Price is your top priority, and you can absorb a 6 to 9 month process.
• Leaks to employees, customers or competitors would not cause real damage.
When does a proprietary or targeted sale make sense?
• One buyer can get unusual value from your business, for example because it fills a gap in their products or territory, so extra bidders add little.
• Confidentiality is critical, for example because of key customers or a competitive market.
• You care about who buys: culture, keeping your employees, your legacy or your own role after the sale.
• You want to keep your team focused on running the business, not on the sale.
How do you keep leverage in a proprietary deal?
Benchmark value independently before discussing price, so you know what a fair offer is.
Keep one or two alternatives warm, even informally. Buyers bid differently when they believe others are looking.
Set a timeline, with a date for the buyer’s written offer and a date for their review to wrap up.
Negotiate the written offer in detail, including how much cash you get at closing, any money held back or paid later based on performance, and whether you must reinvest, not just the headline price.
Limit exclusivity, the period you agree not to talk to other buyers, to a realistic timeline with a clear way out.
FAQ: Proprietary deals vs. auctions
Do auctions always get a higher price? Not always. Research on large deals found final prices were similar for auctions and negotiated sales. Auctions tend to win when many buyers want the business; negotiation can match them when one buyer gets unusual value from your company and you have other options.
Is a proprietary deal bad for the seller? No, but it puts more risk on you if you don’t know what your business is worth. Buyers prefer negotiated deals because they avoid bidding wars, so get an independent valuation, set deadlines and limit how long you agree to talk to only one buyer.
What is a targeted auction? It’s a sale process where an advisor contacts a short list of buyers chosen because they’re a strong fit. It keeps buyers competing for your business while limiting leaks, distraction and the number of buyers digging into your books.
How long does an auction take compared with a negotiated sale? In that research, auctions averaged 335 days from first talks to close, vs. 283 days for negotiations. The difference sat almost entirely before the deal was signed and announced.
Can I run a proprietary sale without an advisor? You can, but you lose the main protection: a credible alternative buyer. An advisor can benchmark price, quietly test the market and manage terms, which preserves leverage even when you plan to sell to a single buyer.
Where does an M&A advisor fit in the auction vs. proprietary decision?
The right process depends on your business, your buyers and what you want after the sale. An advisor on your side can:
Act for you when a buyer calls. Check what your business is worth, test the offer and quietly bring in other credible buyers, so even a one-buyer deal has competition.
Recommend the right structure. From a single negotiated sale to a targeted process with a short list of best-fit buyers.
Know who is buying. Track which private equity firms, family investment offices and private equity-owned companies are actively buying in your industry, so your buyer list reflects who’s buying now.
Protect your terms. Negotiate the details of the written offer (cash at closing, money held back, payments tied to future performance, reinvestment and exclusivity) before you give up your negotiating power.
How Triwell Partners fits in
Triwell Partners works on the buy side. Private equity firms, family offices and independent sponsors engage us to find founder-owned companies that fit what they want to buy, before a sale process starts. If we reach out about your company, we’ll tell you what kind of buyer is interested and why your business fits, with no obligation to go further. We act for the buyer in those conversations, so keep your own M&A attorney and CPA, and an advisor of your own if you want one, for your side of any deal.
Sources
Law360, “Expediting M&A Deal Processes Via Negotiations Vs. Auctions” (August 2020): Analysis Group review of Liu and Officer data on auction and negotiation timelines and premiums.
Bulow and Klemperer, “Auctions Versus Negotiations,” American Economic Review (1996).
A buyer’s belief that you have other options can be almost as valuable as a full auction.
Thinking about what comes next?
Send us a few lines about where things stand. One of us will reply within one business day, with no obligation to go further.
General information only, not legal, tax or investment advice. Triwell Partners is a buy-side advisor: we are engaged and paid by buyers, not sellers.